Strings are immutable. That means once you've created the string, if another process can dump memory, there's no way (aside from reflection) you can get rid of the data before GC kicks in.
With an array, you can explicitly wipe the data after you're done with it: you can overwrite the array with anything you like, and the password won't be present anywhere in the system, even beforegarbage collection.
So yes, this is a security concern - but even using
char only reduces the window of opportunity for an attacker, and it's only for this specific type of attack.
EDIT: As noted in comments, it's possible that arrays being moved by the garbage collector will leave stray copies of the data in memory. I believe this is implementation-specific - the GC may clear all memory as it goes, to avoid this sort of thing. Even if it does, there's still the time during which the
char contains the actual characters as an attack window.
- answered 5 years ago
- Sandy Hook